And what of those whose job it is to uphold or enforce questionable laws enacted by government. I do not think that shedding clothes will do more harm than create arguments among couples passing by.
Witness police actions against non-violent stunts such as teddy bear catapults at global summits, or citizen complaints of tied-up traffic during demonstrations.
It is not moral for the law to tell someone what not to wear; it is taking the freedom of choice away. The rule of law is man-made and is thus fallible, as in the example presented above.
I remembered the uncomfortable nights spent sleeping on the hard wooden pews of a local church to protest the latest commissioning of a Trident nuclear submarine at the General Dynamics facility in Groton Connecticut. Accordingly, it seems that the only answer to whether or not one is justified in breaking a manmade law is if such a law violates more important, overarching laws that govern essential human rights.
None of these actions were directly connected to my day job at the time, which was running a campaign against offshore oil drilling. To put this in perspective, when 50, people turned up at the National Mall to protest the Keystone XL pipeline last February, it was hailed as the " largest climate rally in US history.
That was really something. Surely breaking the laws of people which perpetuate that crime can be justified. Posted on December 20, by neal Some of you are probably already asking if the title of this article is some kind of a joke, or a trick question. Likewise, PETA activists might have done a nude rally to raise awareness against wearing fur clothing.
But I would offer two observations about what makes civil disobedience most powerful: Both these acts are terrorizing rather than justifying. It might be a small rule they might have broken, but they have done it. To put such a possibility in historical context, one can consider the laws made in Nazi Germany.
Times are changing and with them so will the wants of people. Both these acts are terrorizing rather than justifying. However, breaking the law is not always justified. The member-supported Council of Canadians has engaged in all sorts of civil disobedience, including sandbagging towns and provincial legislatures to point out how rising sea levels would affect them.
Breaking the rules can be the best thing to do in a particular situation. If they are sworn to uphold the Constitution, and they enforce laws which violate the rights of the people, does that make them criminals as well. For instance, segregation laws in the United States are another instance of a morally unjustified law as they clearly violate basic human rights and freedoms.
Jun 10, · When breaking the law is justified. eight-hour workday to women’s right to vote to the end of slavery — all of these involved good people willing to break the law.” more than ever. Oct 24, · There are two situations where it is justifiable to break a law: when following the law leads to greater harm than breaking it, and when the law itself is unjust.
If I were starving, I would have no problem stealing food. Death is a greater harm than property loss. There have been many, many unjust laws throughout history. Mar 28, · I do not know every law but I do know if I respect those around me and treat others as I want to be treated, I am not breaking any law.
Is breaking the law ever justified? Have you ever broken a law and justified it?
Answer Questions. My dad seems determined to ruin my life and I don't know what I can do. I even tried to get a Status: Resolved. Sep 29, · Hence sometimes, breaking the law can be justified.
Breaking the rules can be the best thing to do in a particular situation.
It may not be right according to the. Breaking the law is morally justifiable and acceptable when the law in itself is iniquitous and if that law violates human rights and conscience; Certainly, rules are established for us to follow but we as human beings should be able to differentiate the right and the wrong and incase laws need to be violated for the right cause even with hard consequences, breaking the law can be justified; considering the situations.
Dec 20, · Some of you are probably already asking if the title of this article is some kind of a joke, or a trick question. It isn’t, I honestly want to know if you think that there might be times when breaking the law is justified.Can breaking the law ever be